I’ve read all of the books in this series, but somehow or other, I had missed Death of a Maid at the local library and so got a chance to read both this and Death of a Gentle Lady last week. While Hamish is a fun, if a sometimes somewhat inexplicably motivated. character, it’s his beloved village and Beaton’s pacing that are the charm here. Though not the very best in the series, Maid is a good read about a nasty, blackmailing cleaning lady named Mrs Gillespie whose services Hammish has won in a church raffle and whom he finds death shortly afterward. There’s no shortage of suspects, though frankly I already forget who whacked the old hag with her own metal pail.
Death of a Gentle Lady is, I think, somewhat more original fare for Hammish. Though everyone else finds Mrs. Gentle charming, Hammish sees her as vicious and conniving early. Joined by the family which loathes
her at her imperious command (not unlike Beaton’s Agatha Raisin’s last outing), there’s no shortage of suspects at Mrs. Gentle’s tottering “folly,” or, for that matter, in the neighborhood.
There are numerous suplots, including the villagers staging a production of MacBeth and the hopitalization of Hammish’s nemesis Inspector Blair. And not only does Hammish propose marriage to Mrs. Gentle’s ill-treated maid, but a Russian police woman, a local constable, and BOTH Hammish’s former girlfriends show up to complicate matters.
It’s the 23rd book in this series, all of which I’ve read. Some of it (like Hammish’s romantic problems) gets a little old, but I think I’ll order a few of episodes of the BBC television series, which I’ve not seen, anyway.
Here’s a link to the Wikekpedia list of all the Hammish Macbeth mysteries.

